Lucinda's Secret

Lucinda's Secret

Holly Black

First published 2003

7.87.8 / 10
Score out of 1089 ratingsConfidence 38%: this much of the score is the readers’ own

Affiliate link: buying through it supports BookRank at no extra cost to you.

Our view

“Lucinda’s Secret” is a quick, charming third volume that takes “The Spiderwick Chronicles” deeper into the world of faeries. The Grace children cope with Thimbletack’s attacks, a wounded griffin kept out of sight and the question of the Guide, which only their confused Aunt Lucinda may be able to answer. Some readers single out the illustrations as a highlight. Short enough for a single evening, it makes a good bedtime read for families.

The view of the BookRank editors, written from readers’ ratings and comments. It does not affect the score or the book’s place in a ranking.

About the book

As if being attacked by goblins and a bridge troll weren’t enough, Jared is now being targeted by Thimbletack. Simon is keeping an injured and very hungry griffin hidden in the carriage house. And Mallory is convinced the only way to get things back to normal is to get rid of the Guide. But that doesn’t seem to be an option. With more creatures from Arthur Spiderwick’s Field Guide to the Fantastical World Around You popping up, the Guide seems to be the only protection the Grace kids have. But why do the faeries want it so badly? There’s only one person to go to for answers—their fragile and confused Aunt Lucinda.

Description: publisher’s blurb via Hardcover

Reading order · The Spiderwick Chronicles

Full order & progress →
Score per volume5 volumes on a timeline, 2003 to 2004 · Best-rated volume: The Ironwood Tree
  1. The Field Guide
    The Field Guide2003 · 192 ratingsStart here
    7.77.7 / 10
  2. The Seeing Stone
    The Seeing Stone2003 · 105 ratings
    7.87.8 / 10
  3. Lucinda's Secret
    Lucinda's Secret2003 · 89 ratingsThis book
    7.87.8 / 10
  4. The Ironwood Tree
    The Ironwood Tree2004 · 91 ratings
    7.97.9 / 10
  5. The Wrath of Mulgarath
    The Wrath of Mulgarath2004 · 87 ratings
    7.97.9 / 10

Where the score comes from

The sources average 7.5 across 89 ratings — not yet many, so the reader vote carries 38% of the weight and the rest pulls toward the Fantasy average of 8.0. That is how 7.8 comes out.

SourceAverageRatingsWeight
Hardcover7.589 100%

In this book

Themes this book shares with others — each leads to the best books on it.

If you liked this

The same shelf — Fantasy — and a score of 7.8, the closest to this book.