Head to head

I, Robot vs The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes

The same score from the same sources — here is what separates them anyway.

A tie — identical score

8.28.2 / 10

I, RobotIsaac Asimov

8.2	Score	8.2
1,723	ratings	366
#3	Rank in Short stories	#4
#36	Rank in Classics	#40
1950	First published	1894
245	Pages	259

8.28.2 / 10

The Memoirs of Sherlock HolmesArthur Conan Doyle

Practically level: I, Robot — 8.2 from 1,723 ratings, The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes — 8.2 from 366. Both are ranked in Short stories (54 titles): I, Robot at #3, The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes at #4.